The Papa
yarn substitutes · what to use when you cannot get the one the pattern says

This is a starting point, not a promise.Knit a swatch before you commit the whole sweater.

Substitutes for Heirloom Merino Magic Chunky 125gm

weight
chunky
thickness
96 m per 100 g
put-up
125 g
fibre
50% Merino, 50% Wool
in Australia
listed by 1 Australian shop we track

closest first

Cascade Yarns - 220 Superwash Grande
chunky · 100 m/100g · 200g · 50% Merino, 50% Wool
  • machine washable, where the original is hand wash only
  • sold in 200g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Fiddlesticks - Peppin 14ply
chunky · 97 m/100g · 100g · 100% Merino
  • machine washable, where the original is hand wash only
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Fiddlesticks - Peppin 14
chunky · 98 m/100g · 100g · 100% Wool
  • machine washable, where the original is hand wash only
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Yarns On Shannon Avenue - Cozee
chunky · 100 m/100g · 100g · 82% Alpaca, 18% Cotton
  • less springy -- it will grow and not bounce back
  • drapier, hanging softer
  • shinier
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Cleckheaton - Midlands Merino 12ply
aran · 120 m/100g · 100g · 100% Merino
  • thinner: 120 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 25% difference in yardage needed
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Amano Yarns - Yana by Amano Yarns
chunky · 80 m/100g · 200g · 100% Wool
  • thicker: 80 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 17% difference in yardage needed
  • sold in 200g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Circus Tonic - Handmade
aran · 120 m/100g · 50g · 75% Merino, 25% Nylon
  • thinner: 120 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 25% difference in yardage needed
  • sold in 50g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Fiddlesticks - Superb Big
chunky · 80 m/100g · 100g · 100% Acrylic
  • thicker: 80 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 17% difference in yardage needed
  • cooler
  • less springy -- it will grow and not bounce back
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Yarns On Shannon Avenue - 12 PLY
chunky · 110 m/100g · 100g · 75% Acrylic, 25% Nylon
  • thinner: 110 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 15% difference in yardage needed
  • cooler
  • less springy -- it will grow and not bounce back
  • less soft next to skin
  • machine washable, where the original is hand wash only
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Yarns On Shannon Avenue - Fiddlesticks
chunky · 80 m/100g · 100g · 100% Acrylic
  • thicker: 80 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 17% difference in yardage needed
  • cooler
  • less springy -- it will grow and not bounce back
  • machine washable, where the original is hand wash only
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
La Bien Aimée - Merino DK
dk · 200 m/100g · 115g · 100% Merino
  • thinner: 200 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 108% difference in yardage needed
  • sold in 115g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs
Rainbows and Sprinkles - Pixie Garden
fingering · 400 m/100g · 100g · 85% Merino, 15% Nylon
  • thinner: 400 m/100g against 96 -- expect a 317% difference in yardage needed
  • sold in 100g put-ups, not 125g -- check how many balls the pattern needs

how this was worked out

Thickness comes from metreage per 100 g, which is a measurement. Fibre behaviour - warmth, halo, springiness, drape - is scored per fibre and blended by proportion, so a merino and a Bluefaced Leicester read as near neighbours while a merino and a cotton do not, even at the same gauge. Where a record is thin, the match is discounted rather than quietly flattered, and the gap is named above.

Yardage is always rounded up. If we ever sell you the yarn and the number is short, the extra skein is on us, from your dye lot.